Neighbor's solar horror story

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • skipro3
    Solar Fanatic
    • Jul 2015
    • 172

    #1

    Neighbor's solar horror story

    My neighbor, 78 years old now, who lives across the street has a real solar horror story I though folks here would find interesting.

    He bought the house across the street several years ago as a second home. He came up on weekends to relax, eventually wanting to retire. About 4 or 5 years ago, he decided to put solar on the house. It's about 3.3kWh system. Since he was rarely there, he didn't pay much attention to it. One day about 3 years ago, his son was caught without work and moved into the house to help save money. My neighbor got the electric bills and they were high; around $500 to $600 a month. He told the kid to take it easy and to conserve. But you know kids and especially kids with kids; there were 6 of them living in the house, son, wife and 4 kids. They moved out after about a year and a year later, my neighbor retired and moved up permanently. His bills jumped back up to $500/$600 a month. Two years goes by and I decided to get solar and talk to him about it. He's none too happy, saying his bill is actually higher with solar. I shrug and go forward with my install. After I install, I get a Rainforest Eagle. I show it to my neighbor and he gets one.

    That's when he discovers that he is not getting the solar credited to his account. (He didn't realize he should not have been getting a monthly bill, just a true-up once a year) He calls PG&E and sure enough, they do NOT have him as a solar customer. They tell him to immediately disconnect his solar from their grid and that he is a criminal for having it connected in the first place. Neighbor calls the installer, who is subbed out from the company he hired to do the solar and he can't prove he submitted the paperwork to PG&E to get PTO. He said it was the company he bought the system from, not him the contractor subbing the labor.

    So Neighbor files to have the PTO, but now it's 4+ years and the codes have changed. His plan is not up to standards. The installer contractor calls PG&E and over the phone they get it worked out and 2 days later he gets PTO.

    Here's what happened with his bill;
    All the energy, both from the grid and to the grid was billed as power used by him. He's on TOU and solar of course, generates heavy during peak rate time. He's paying 35 cents a kWh to put electricity on the grid!!! FOR FOUR PLUS YEARS THIS HAS BEEN GOING ON!!!

    Neighbor has had a smart meter on the house for 2 years and that's 2 years AFTER the solar was installed. He spoke to the PG&E installer who assured him he's on the solar rate, so what doubts the neighbor had, are no longer on radar. PG&E refuses to make adjustment to his bill, although they do admit they can determine exactly how much power he would have been saving and banking. It totalled to a bit over $6,000. PG&E pretty much tells him to suck eggs, they aren't going to comp him energy, or repay the over charge he had for pushing watts to the their grid.

    I suggested he contact the CPUC and if that doesn't get him anywhere, to contact the local News TV station and the local paper and give them a sob story about elder abuse; how the big, bad electric company stole over $6,000 from him after he asked them about the solar when the smart meter was installed.

    I doubt he'll get a dime or a watt of credit back, but wow-o-wow!!

    Neighbor figures he can't live long enough to re-coup his expenses now for having put solar on his house. BTW, he paid somewhat more than $30,000 for his solar all those years ago, on a loan and continues to make the loan payments on top of a $500/$600 monthly bill for those years. He'll still have to pay on the loan, but at least NOW he's offsetting it with his solar.
  • solarix
    Super Moderator
    • Apr 2015
    • 1415

    #2
    Yep, its a brave new world and no one is on your side. I know I spend most of my time dealing with bureaucratic bs.
    BSEE, R11, NABCEP, Chevy BoltEV, >3000kW installed

    Comment

    • solar pete
      Administrator
      • May 2014
      • 1827

      #3
      Originally posted by skipro3
      My neighbor, 78 years old now, who lives across the street has a real solar horror story I though folks here would find interesting.

      He bought the house across the street several years ago as a second home. He came up on weekends to relax, eventually wanting to retire. About 4 or 5 years ago, he decided to put solar on the house. It's about 3.3kWh system. Since he was rarely there, he didn't pay much attention to it. One day about 3 years ago, his son was caught without work and moved into the house to help save money. My neighbor got the electric bills and they were high; around $500 to $600 a month. He told the kid to take it easy and to conserve. But you know kids and especially kids with kids; there were 6 of them living in the house, son, wife and 4 kids. They moved out after about a year and a year later, my neighbor retired and moved up permanently. His bills jumped back up to $500/$600 a month. Two years goes by and I decided to get solar and talk to him about it. He's none too happy, saying his bill is actually higher with solar. I shrug and go forward with my install. After I install, I get a Rainforest Eagle. I show it to my neighbor and he gets one.

      That's when he discovers that he is not getting the solar credited to his account. (He didn't realize he should not have been getting a monthly bill, just a true-up once a year) He calls PG&E and sure enough, they do NOT have him as a solar customer. They tell him to immediately disconnect his solar from their grid and that he is a criminal for having it connected in the first place. Neighbor calls the installer, who is subbed out from the company he hired to do the solar and he can't prove he submitted the paperwork to PG&E to get PTO. He said it was the company he bought the system from, not him the contractor subbing the labor.

      So Neighbor files to have the PTO, but now it's 4+ years and the codes have changed. His plan is not up to standards. The installer contractor calls PG&E and over the phone they get it worked out and 2 days later he gets PTO.

      Here's what happened with his bill;
      All the energy, both from the grid and to the grid was billed as power used by him. He's on TOU and solar of course, generates heavy during peak rate time. He's paying 35 cents a kWh to put electricity on the grid!!! FOR FOUR PLUS YEARS THIS HAS BEEN GOING ON!!!

      Neighbor has had a smart meter on the house for 2 years and that's 2 years AFTER the solar was installed. He spoke to the PG&E installer who assured him he's on the solar rate, so what doubts the neighbor had, are no longer on radar. PG&E refuses to make adjustment to his bill, although they do admit they can determine exactly how much power he would have been saving and banking. It totalled to a bit over $6,000. PG&E pretty much tells him to suck eggs, they aren't going to comp him energy, or repay the over charge he had for pushing watts to the their grid.

      I suggested he contact the CPUC and if that doesn't get him anywhere, to contact the local News TV station and the local paper and give them a sob story about elder abuse; how the big, bad electric company stole over $6,000 from him after he asked them about the solar when the smart meter was installed.

      I doubt he'll get a dime or a watt of credit back, but wow-o-wow!!

      Neighbor figures he can't live long enough to re-coup his expenses now for having put solar on his house. BTW, he paid somewhat more than $30,000 for his solar all those years ago, on a loan and continues to make the loan payments on top of a $500/$600 monthly bill for those years. He'll still have to pay on the loan, but at least NOW he's offsetting it with his solar.
      Wow, that really does make me angry. Would you please PM me the name of the company that sold the system, cheers.

      Comment

      • skipro3
        Solar Fanatic
        • Jul 2015
        • 172

        #4
        Originally posted by solar pete
        Wow, that really does make me angry. Would you please PM me the name of the company that sold the system, cheers.
        I'll ask him who it was, but I think they are no longer in business. I do know the installer is and that's who intervened and got PTO for him.

        Comment

        • emartin00
          Solar Fanatic
          • Aug 2013
          • 511

          #5
          I doubt he would ever get the money from the electric company. The better thing to do would be to sue the installer. The work was not performed as per the contract, and the contractor/installer should be paying that money back to him.

          Comment

          • skipro3
            Solar Fanatic
            • Jul 2015
            • 172

            #6
            Originally posted by emartin00
            I doubt he would ever get the money from the electric company. The better thing to do would be to sue the installer. The work was not performed as per the contract, and the contractor/installer should be paying that money back to him.
            I doubt it too. Unless the electric company is under some sort of pressure to make the correction, they probably won't do the right thing.

            Problem with suing the installer is; the company he contracted with is no longer in business. They sub contracted the labor and that guy knew nothing about the paperwork; permits, permission to operate forms, etc. so there isn't anyone they can sue other than the electric company itself.

            Comment

            • SunEagle
              Super Moderator
              • Oct 2012
              • 15161

              #7
              Sad story. If anything everyone who reads this thread needs to understand that just because they install a solar pv system does not mean it has been approved by their POCO or if their electric meter has been programmed to Net Meter.

              We have had similar stories (it may be due to different reasons and for shorter time frames) about people turning on their pv system before the POCO tells them it is ok because owner wants to start saving money. Then they find out that they "paid" for every kWh they generated because their meter was not configured and did not "subtract" the kWh they generated but added it instead.

              IMO it is not worth jumping the gun to turn on your pv system before you get the green light. Haste can cost you.

              Comment

              • foo1bar
                Solar Fanatic
                • Aug 2014
                • 1833

                #8
                Originally posted by SunEagle

                IMO it is not worth jumping the gun to turn on your pv system before you get the green light. Haste can cost you.
                It is certainly possible to wind up paying extra for the solar power you generate.
                There ARE meters that never turn backwards.
                So people DO need to be careful.

                OTOH, my meter before POCO signed off on my install was a mechanical meter from 1970's, and it spun backwards while I was testing my array.
                (spun backwards fast/far enough that I didn't have any power billed for the month before my solar install was "official")
                When the POCO switched my account over to net billing, they replaced the mechanical meter with a "smart" meter.

                Comment

                • inetdog
                  Super Moderator
                  • May 2012
                  • 9909

                  #9
                  Originally posted by foo1bar
                  OTOH, my meter before POCO signed off on my install was a mechanical meter from 1970's, and it spun backwards while I was testing my array.
                  (spun backwards fast/far enough that I didn't have any power billed for the month before my solar install was "official")
                  When the POCO switched my account over to net billing, they replaced the mechanical meter with a "smart" meter.

                  It worked out for you just fine, but others should be aware that the disk spinning backwards does not necessarily mean that the dials will be spinning backward too.
                  SunnyBoy 3000 US, 18 BP Solar 175B panels.

                  Comment

                  • skipro3
                    Solar Fanatic
                    • Jul 2015
                    • 172

                    #10
                    My neighbor is still trying to get PG&E to do the right thing and give him a refund of his over payment. Neighbor told me that PG&E can 'see' that 'channel C' indeed shows the power pushed to the grid but that they are under no obligation to make corrections to his account and she said they won't.

                    Comment

                    • diogenes
                      Solar Fanatic
                      • Jul 2015
                      • 175

                      #11
                      I would contact the local state and federal congresspeople immediately. also newspapers and tv stations.

                      Comment

                      • Willaby
                        Solar Fanatic
                        • Jun 2015
                        • 205

                        #12
                        On one hand he should have known better from the beginning, especially after getting and paying larger bills he should have reviewed the contract and inquired. On the other hand, if the credits can be calculated, they should be. Regarding knowing better though, he's in his 70's, not sure if that's an issue as I might not be quite as sharp when I get there.

                        Reminds me of a story about a year ago whereby a resident hadn't received a water bill for years and the water department billed him based on an adjacent usage estimate, several $thou. I don't know how it turned out, but the resident was saying "no, I owe nothing". Legal costs probably did not favor him to fight, better to negotiate down, but he did get on tv and maybe that helped.

                        Comment

                        • Naptown
                          Solar Fanatic
                          • Feb 2011
                          • 6880

                          #13
                          All a good try however if he turned on the system prior to getting permission to operate from the utility because the installer or whoever didn't follow the procedure there is little he can do.
                          If he can document the paperwork being filed and the poco never responded that is a different story.
                          NABCEP certified Technical Sales Professional

                          [URL="http://www.solarpaneltalk.com/showthread.php?5334-Solar-Off-Grid-Battery-Design"]http://www.solarpaneltalk.com/showth...Battery-Design[/URL]

                          [URL]http://www.calculator.net/voltage-drop-calculator.html[/URL] (Voltage drop Calculator among others)

                          [URL="http://www.gaisma.com"]www.gaisma.com[/URL]

                          Comment

                          • skipro3
                            Solar Fanatic
                            • Jul 2015
                            • 172

                            #14
                            Thanks for all the replies and suggestions. They really help. As noted, he is in his 70's and has LOTS of other problems besides the solar one. It's just that the solar is probably all I'm going to be able to help him with. For example; his wife has Alzheimers and had to be put in a home this year. He's having to worry which will go first; his money or his wife. It costs a lot to keep her in a home that can give her care. If his money runs out first, he has to sell his house. Hoping that now he ISN'T paying $500-$600 a month to the electric company, he might be able to hang in there longer. He's had 3 surgeries himself in the past year; hernia and two knee surgeries. His kids are near worthless; without jobs, several grandkids, one son just got out of prison.
                            He's really a nice man and I help where I can; leaf blowing his walkways and driveway, Heavy lifting, etc... He worked hard all his life, told me before he finally retired in order to take care of his ill wife that 14 people counted on him for his paycheck. (Side note; my own kids would never get away with that. I'm not a nice man like my neighbor....) Now that he's old, retired and without a bucket of money coming in regular, the kids and grandkids are nowhere to be found except for the one who was in prison. He helps his dad, but lost his driver license (I guess it was a drunk driving issue, don't know why he was in prison.)

                            I guess the MAIN lesson here is this;
                            Do NOT get into solar unless you either have SOME clue what electricity even is. He didn't. He got solar mainly because he felt it's the ecologically responsible thing to do and would help reduce carbon footprint. (And all the rest of that liberal, feel-good crap the bunny huggers try to feed us)
                            Do NOT trust contractors. If you don't know the technicals, find someone you can trust to do that part for you who can tell you if your contractor is doing his job right. At the risk of insulting contractors, (of which I'm of the mind that they are a lot like lawyers, most contractors feel a project cost is THEIR money and they have to figure out how to get you to go away for a cheap as they can, and keep as much of THEIR money as they can in the process.)
                            Learn to read your electric bill. Neighbor didn't know how. He learned when I showed him my Rainforest Eagle unit and how I could track power use. He later told me he got a real sinking dread feeling after seeing that on my computer with my meter and use. He KNEW right then that something major was wrong with his billing.

                            How his contractor failed him in so many ways is beyond me. To not inform him of the process and steps to get his system up and running legal-like, how his new billing would look, his estimated reduction in his overall power bill, etc... If his contractor wasn't already out of business, I'd help my neighbor hire an attorney to sue that asshat!

                            Right now, Neighbor is in process of contacting CPUC after many hours and phone calls with PG&E to document and discover what they know about his particular situation and gathering his own documentation. Contacting his congressman is a great idea! Thanks! I'll let him know today. He has a call to the local newspaper about his solar situation. I might call them too to offer up my own, neighbor perspective; how I've helped him discover he's been cheated out of the solar benefits, how neighbor is a kind, gentle man who has spent his life helping his own family, how his retirement years are now worried about loosing his house and his wife by Christmas, etc... I'm hoping that somehow, PG&E will grow a heart and and see the publicity risk AND opportunity with helping Neighbor out.

                            Comment

                            • Naptown
                              Solar Fanatic
                              • Feb 2011
                              • 6880

                              #15
                              When all else fails try them in the court of public opinion.
                              NABCEP certified Technical Sales Professional

                              [URL="http://www.solarpaneltalk.com/showthread.php?5334-Solar-Off-Grid-Battery-Design"]http://www.solarpaneltalk.com/showth...Battery-Design[/URL]

                              [URL]http://www.calculator.net/voltage-drop-calculator.html[/URL] (Voltage drop Calculator among others)

                              [URL="http://www.gaisma.com"]www.gaisma.com[/URL]

                              Comment

                              Working...