I'm not sure Trombe walls fell out of favor (if they were ever in favor) as much as people discovered/figured out that thermal mass didn't need to be placed directly against a window, thus blocking the view to be effective - as in, among other tricks, putting the heavy stuff in the sun and make that stuff as dark in color as possible, and letting the lightweight stuff be light in color to bounce the sun around until it hits something dark (and heavy). Lots of other tricks/considerations helped some folks realize that Trombe walls are little more than a specialized and somewhat limited (and limiting) use of thermal mass.
I had thermal storage in a sunspace I added to an existing dwelling in the early '80's. it consisted of the Kalwall fiberglass cylinders (18" dia. X ~ 10 ft high) containing black dyed H2O against the back wall of the space were it got close to max. solar exposure - somewhat less biased to morning sun for slightly more afternoon storage potential. There was a black curtain directly in front of the cylinders that could be raised/lowered via a thermostat w/ a manual override for partial exposure of the H2O or as wanted/needed. The curtain was usually down in the A.M. and went up if/when the ambient temp. in the sunspace reached ~ +80 F. or so if/when the sun was shining, which was about 60 useful hrs./month during Buffalo, NY winters. I estimate I got most or more of the storage and temp. mod. benefits of a Trombe wall and still got to use the space as more than a dark room with a warm monolith on the south wall (warm on sunny afternoons/evenings anyway, but I'd speculate colder than a welldigger's ass on winter mornings).
I had thermal storage in a sunspace I added to an existing dwelling in the early '80's. it consisted of the Kalwall fiberglass cylinders (18" dia. X ~ 10 ft high) containing black dyed H2O against the back wall of the space were it got close to max. solar exposure - somewhat less biased to morning sun for slightly more afternoon storage potential. There was a black curtain directly in front of the cylinders that could be raised/lowered via a thermostat w/ a manual override for partial exposure of the H2O or as wanted/needed. The curtain was usually down in the A.M. and went up if/when the ambient temp. in the sunspace reached ~ +80 F. or so if/when the sun was shining, which was about 60 useful hrs./month during Buffalo, NY winters. I estimate I got most or more of the storage and temp. mod. benefits of a Trombe wall and still got to use the space as more than a dark room with a warm monolith on the south wall (warm on sunny afternoons/evenings anyway, but I'd speculate colder than a welldigger's ass on winter mornings).
Comment