X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • nsgoldberg
    replied
    If I derate my main from 200A to 175A, that gives me 65A of backfeed, which is enough for a 10kW system.

    I'm confident 175A is sufficient for the home, even if I went with a separate EV charger, which would require a 40A circuit. The largest load on the house is the A/C (40A circuit).

    My question is, would electrical load calcs be required for this? How is the panel typically derated? Is a separate permit required for this, or is it part of the PV inspection? Can I just buy a 175A main and swap it out?

    EDIT: Just for a sanity check, did a load calc and determined max load to be 28kW and 37kW with an EV charger, which would require a 100A panel (up to 48kW)

    I'm thinking if I can find a 175A breaker to fit my MSP, that's the way to go. A MSP replacement in the future would be nice, but I'm short on funds for that at the moment.
    Last edited by nsgoldberg; 06-28-2019, 08:16 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • nsgoldberg
    replied
    Originally posted by ButchDeal

    I would HIGHLY suggest that you use the IronRidge flashing system and not get some flashing from Homedepot.
    https://www.ironridge.com/pitched-ro...ng-flashfoot2/
    I will definitely take your advice on that, thanks!

    Edit: I have concrete tile, it looks like that system is for shingled roofs. I will be mounting it with the angled brackets that fit under the tiles (Ironridge All Tile Hook). The flashing was for electrical conduit connections only.
    Last edited by nsgoldberg; 06-28-2019, 06:59 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • ButchDeal
    replied
    Originally posted by nsgoldberg
    Also comes with IronRidge XR100 Racking, clips, hardware, labeling, grounding bars kit, disconnect, etc.
    I would only need to purchase the wire, conduit, and flashing to complete the system (Home Depot, est. $600).
    I would HIGHLY suggest that you use the IronRidge flashing system and not get some flashing from Homedepot.
    The strongest attachment in solar. IronRidge FlashFoot2® raises the bar in solar roof protection. The unique water seal is both elevated and encapsulated, delivering redundant layers of protection against water intrusion.

    Leave a comment:


  • ButchDeal
    replied
    Originally posted by nsgoldberg
    Great info, thanks for the quick response! I see now, there's an 80% deration, so it's not based on 40A, but actually 32A.
    no it is based on a 40A breaker in the MSP.
    The 40A breaker is based on the derate and requirements of the inverters. THUS, a 7.6kW inverter spits out 32A and requires a 40A breaker AND that is the max you can fit on an older 200A MSP with a 200A buss.

    Leave a comment:


  • nsgoldberg
    replied
    Originally posted by ButchDeal

    do you have a flat roof? you need firecode setback on your roof which are generally 3 feet from ridge and rake (simplified a bit)

    https://www.renvu.com/Learn/New-Cali...-July-1st-2018
    This is great info, thanks! According to this, then yes, I will need 3' from ridge and side. I don't have a flat roof.

    This will make it more difficult to place the panels I've chosen. I may need to go with the 60 cell for a better fit. I made a drawing in AutoCAD for it, so I'll have to play with that a bit.

    Leave a comment:


  • nsgoldberg
    replied
    Great info, thanks for the quick response! I see now, there's an 80% deration, so it's not based on 40A, but actually 32A.

    Apparently my PoCo (SCE), has meter adapters already set up for line side taps just for solar. They're called "Generation Meter Adapters" or GMA. There are pictures of it on page 20 here:


    This may be the best route. Edison will install the GMA (it's really just a spacer) for close to $500 and connect it to your disconnect. Kind of a rip off for $500, but still cheaper and easier than MSP replacement, even if I do the work myself.

    Leave a comment:


  • ButchDeal
    replied
    Originally posted by nsgoldberg
    Found this regarding roof space:

    "Identify any existing mechanical equipment on the roof plan and provide a minimum working clearance of 36" around the entire unit as well as a minimum 24" wide clear accessway from the roof scuttle or roof access point. (NEC 110.26 and CMC 904.10)"

    So I believe it's OK to go to the edge of the roof, provided you have 24" clear where you will climb onto the roof.

    do you have a flat roof? you need firecode setback on your roof which are generally 3 feet from ridge and rake (simplified a bit)

    RENVU is a leading solar equipment distributor offering high-quality products, competitive pricing, and exceptional service. Get the best solar solutions for your projects—fast shipping, expert support, and top brands you trust.

    Leave a comment:


  • ButchDeal
    replied
    Originally posted by nsgoldberg
    I hadn't considered the need for a lineside tap or derating my MSP. I realize now this is a big issue, especially once I add the charger for an EV.
    As I suggested you can get the SE7600H with built in inverter so only one 40A breaker.


    Originally posted by nsgoldberg
    If I have a 200A breaker and bus, isn't that 40A or 9.6kW?
    No a 7.6kW inverter requires a 40A breaker

    Originally posted by nsgoldberg
    The additional panels would be the same azimuth and tilt.
    Then if there is no shadows you will have some clipping unless you add another inverter like the SE3800H later.

    Originally posted by nsgoldberg
    I have an older breaker panel that uses a strange main breaker. I don't ever flip it, because half the time I do, it won't reset. You can't find them new, but there's a company in LA that rebuilds them for $300. I've had to do that twice now to get power back on in the house. I'm considering upgrading the entire panel to a modern one. That might be a good time to install a line side tap. How common is this, and what costs would be incurred in putting that in? I'm guessing I would need to hire an electrician to do that, and another ($$$) permit from the county.
    Same permit can be used but you can get new 200A MSP with higher amp bus which would allow a larger inverter without a lineside tap. This would be the way to go.

    Originally posted by nsgoldberg
    Perhaps I should just stick with the 7.6kW inverter. But, if I expand later, that's going to require a derate, correct?
    or you could replace the MSP at that time.

    Originally posted by nsgoldberg
    On another note, the sum of the breakers in my 200A panel is 470A. Would that be an issue during inspection?
    That is common as you generally do not run EVERYTHING at once. and most of the items on those breakers are not maxed out.

    Leave a comment:


  • nsgoldberg
    replied
    Found this regarding roof space:

    "Identify any existing mechanical equipment on the roof plan and provide a minimum working clearance of 36" around the entire unit as well as a minimum 24" wide clear accessway from the roof scuttle or roof access point. (NEC 110.26 and CMC 904.10)"

    So I believe it's OK to go to the edge of the roof, provided you have 24" clear where you will climb onto the roof.


    Leave a comment:


  • nsgoldberg
    replied
    Wow, a lot of great tips and suggestions here, thank you all! Did some research on what was said here before responding.

    Originally posted by Markyrocks69
    The only thing I can say is that you could probably save some money by sourcing the equipment from different vendors. That's not going to be as convenient as a all inclusive kit but I paid around the same price for a system twice that size.

    Also be aware that if you're planning on doing the install yourself that those panels are big. So going to be a challenge getting them onto a roof without a second person or a machine.
    I'm going to look at this, do you have a recommended source? I plan on using my neighbor's tractor to lift them on the roof. (One side is relatively low).

    Originally posted by JSchnee21
    Welcome nsgoldberg!

    Sounds like you've got this planned out pretty well! Some general comments:

    1) You PoCo may give you a hard time with the PV array size and projected production being great than 100% of current historical usage. Some tolerate up to 110-120%. Other's don't seem to check the estimated production (PVWatts) very carefully so sometimes you can get away with estimating low.

    2) I don't have any experience with the Mission Solar panels so I cannot comment one way or another, but they see to have gotten a decent rating on EnergySage if that's worth anything -- maybe, maybe not. But in general, panels are a commodity, and most mid tier panels are fine. The Temperature Coefficient of Pmax is -0.375%/
    You're right, I wasn't aware of this, thanks!

    Originally posted by ButchDeal
    with an inverter over 7.6kW you will have to have a lineside tap or derate you MSP most likely.

    Since you are planning to add an EV charger you could save a bit of money and have a much simpler interconnect (assuming a 200a MSP) without a lineside tape or derate bu using the SE7600H, further you could get the SE7600H with a built in EV charger.

    You say that all the PV modules will be on the same azimuth and tilt but will the expansion be on the same azimuth and tilt? if not then the SE7600H may not clip even with over paneling.
    even so you can go a bit over 7.6kW with modest clipping and/or add an SE3800h for expansion latter.

    https://www.solaredge.com/us/products/ev-charger#/
    I hadn't considered the need for a lineside tap or derating my MSP. I realize now this is a big issue, especially once I add the charger for an EV.

    If I have a 200A breaker and bus, isn't that 40A or 9.6kW?

    The additional panels would be the same azimuth and tilt.

    I have an older breaker panel that uses a strange main breaker. I don't ever flip it, because half the time I do, it won't reset. You can't find them new, but there's a company in LA that rebuilds them for $300. I've had to do that twice now to get power back on in the house. I'm considering upgrading the entire panel to a modern one. That might be a good time to install a line side tap. How common is this, and what costs would be incurred in putting that in? I'm guessing I would need to hire an electrician to do that, and another ($$$) permit from the county.

    Perhaps I should just stick with the 7.6kW inverter. But, if I expand later, that's going to require a derate, correct?

    On another note, the sum of the breakers in my 200A panel is 470A. Would that be an issue during inspection?


    Originally posted by J.P.M.
    Welcome to the neighborhood.

    I worked in the Inland Empire for several years when I first moved to CA, now retired in 92026. Now have a mostly unobstructed view to the north from the San Gabriels all the way past the west end of Big Bear to San Gorgonio. Smile for the camera.

    How much clearance are you designing for roof to bottom of panel frame ? Respectful suggestion: The more the better.

    Also, if not done so already, check roof setback requirements per CA/Riverside co. fire codes.

    Assuming SCE is your POCO, on SCE and size limitations etc.: You've probably seen the SCE application checklist by NEM program type, but if not, it might be worth your time. It looks like you will need "electrical system sizing documentation" for a system w/est. output > prior 12 months and so jump through that hoop if a system's whose proposed estimated annual production based on their NEM interconnection handbook is > prior 12 month's usage. But it look to be STC wattage restricted beyond the required forms to be filed being different for < vs > 10 kW STC size.

    Lastly, get your roof inspected/serviced if/as you think necessary. Cheap insurance you will not regret. PV will last a long time. Chasing roof leaks is bad enough. Chasing them under an array is a nearly impossible task. Give the roof the best chance of lasting at least as long as the array.

    Regards,

    Add: almost missed it: You may need another jump through another hoop if you do need a line side tap as Butch writes.
    Very nice! I like that area. I remember reading 3' roof setback, I have it currently planned for ~2'. I've been paying attention to installations all around the county, and most are right to the edge of the roof. So it doesn't seem to be something the county is strict about.

    You're right, I will need documentation for a larger installation. Hopefully they will accept the rationale of planning on buying an EV.

    Our roof is in great shape, but I think I'll pull some tiles to confirm prior to installation, and do a good look underneath in the attic. Thanks for the tip!

    Originally posted by foo1bar

    I'd look at other vendors. I think you can do better than $11k.
    I'd look at renvu, soligent.

    I did a DIY install with 60-cell panels, and those were awkward to handle - 72-cell panels are going to be singificantly worse IMO.
    Also - I would look at lower efficient (but better $/W) panels.
    For example, you could get 72-cell 365W for $180.20/panel ($.49/W)
    26 of those would give you more power for cheaper I think.
    There's some cost per-panel for optimizer, rails, etc. etc. So it isn't all about the per-panel cost (just mostly)
    I'd also look at 60-cell 275W @ $.45/W (more optimizers, but easier to handle I think)
    Good point, I think I'll take a look at the smaller panels. Easier to install, and easier to fit in spaces on the roof.

    Leave a comment:


  • foo1bar
    replied
    Originally posted by nsgoldberg
    Hi All,
    I'm looking at a 7.5kW system on WholesaleSolar.com ($11,000):
    Panels: 20 Mission Solar 375W Silver Mono PERC
    I'd look at other vendors. I think you can do better than $11k.
    I'd look at renvu, soligent.

    I did a DIY install with 60-cell panels, and those were awkward to handle - 72-cell panels are going to be singificantly worse IMO.
    Also - I would look at lower efficient (but better $/W) panels.
    For example, you could get 72-cell 365W for $180.20/panel ($.49/W)
    26 of those would give you more power for cheaper I think.
    There's some cost per-panel for optimizer, rails, etc. etc. So it isn't all about the per-panel cost (just mostly)
    I'd also look at 60-cell 275W @ $.45/W (more optimizers, but easier to handle I think)

    Leave a comment:


  • J.P.M.
    replied
    Welcome to the neighborhood.

    I worked in the Inland Empire for several years when I first moved to CA, now retired in 92026. Now have a mostly unobstructed view to the north from the San Gabriels all the way past the west end of Big Bear to San Gorgonio. Smile for the camera.

    How much clearance are you designing for roof to bottom of panel frame ? Respectful suggestion: The more the better.

    Also, if not done so already, check roof setback requirements per CA/Riverside co. fire codes.

    Assuming SCE is your POCO, on SCE and size limitations etc.: You've probably seen the SCE application checklist by NEM program type, but if not, it might be worth your time. It looks like you will need "electrical system sizing documentation" for a system w/est. output > prior 12 months and so jump through that hoop if a system's whose proposed estimated annual production based on their NEM interconnection handbook is > prior 12 month's usage. But it look to be STC wattage restricted beyond the required forms to be filed being different for < vs > 10 kW STC size.

    Lastly, get your roof inspected/serviced if/as you think necessary. Cheap insurance you will not regret. PV will last a long time. Chasing roof leaks is bad enough. Chasing them under an array is a nearly impossible task. Give the roof the best chance of lasting at least as long as the array.

    Regards,

    Add: almost missed it: You may need another jump through another hoop if you do need a line side tap as Butch writes.
    Last edited by J.P.M.; 06-27-2019, 11:59 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • ButchDeal
    replied
    with an inverter over 7.6kW you will have to have a lineside tap or derate you MSP most likely.

    Since you are planning to add an EV charger you could save a bit of money and have a much simpler interconnect (assuming a 200a MSP) without a lineside tape or derate bu using the SE7600H, further you could get the SE7600H with a built in EV charger.

    You say that all the PV modules will be on the same azimuth and tilt but will the expansion be on the same azimuth and tilt? if not then the SE7600H may not clip even with over paneling.
    even so you can go a bit over 7.6kW with modest clipping and/or add an SE3800h for expansion latter.

    Transform your businesses and residences into an eco-friendly energy hub using the SolarEdge inverter solution and the SolarEdge energy manager platform.

    Leave a comment:


  • JSchnee21
    replied
    oh darn, it clipped the rest of my post

    Leave a comment:


  • JSchnee21
    replied
    Welcome nsgoldberg!

    Sounds like you've got this planned out pretty well! Some general comments:

    1) You PoCo may give you a hard time with the PV array size and projected production being great than 100% of current historical usage. Some tolerate up to 110-120%. Other's don't seem to check the estimated production (PVWatts) very carefully so sometimes you can get away with estimating low.

    2) I don't have any experience with the Mission Solar panels so I cannot comment one way or another, but they see to have gotten a decent rating on EnergySage if that's worth anything -- maybe, maybe not. But in general, panels are a commodity, and most mid tier panels are fine. The Temperature Coefficient of Pmax is -0.375%/

    Leave a comment:

Working...