Some great advice and going through a similar experience RIGHT now.
In my case I'm going with a well known reputable installer in my area (Sullivan, which many here have used and one of the reasons why I decided to go with them). At any rate even in the contract language (I checked), in my case they warranty the roof work for 10 years against leaks. Now having a functional non-leaking roof doesn't necessarily mean a pristine looking roof with no tiles that were repaired by glue.
My entire roof is Spanish concrete tiles, now it's more durable than the flat concrete tiles which are real brittle but none the less I've had my share of headaches with broken tiles, already 10 cracks and I'm considered a small install 4.23KW (only 18 panels).
Worst one of the installers stepped in that black stuff they use to seal the bolts into the roof (under the tiles) and now have a number of "follow the footprints" on my roof -- argh!!!
I even got 21 extra tiles, yet when I went to the roof to check progress they went ahead and decided to just glue (okay if it's a clean single break -- fine, but some of them are multiple lines and the glue just looks real sloppy).
Maybe I'm too small of a job for them to care about so they want to get done as quick as possible (gluing cheaper than replacing) but still.
In reality:
- gluing a clean tile break does work (confirmed with my roofing company that it's a valid repair -- this goes into it works but ain't pretty pile -- if that's the case then duct tape probably work too!)
- talking to my builder the Spanish tiles are more for aesthetics (yes it does repeal rain) but the real protection is the sheeting that's underneath
- I have a tall two story roof and where the cracked tiles are no one will be able to tell unless you're walking on the roof (although this argument doesn't work too well with the wife since just because she can't see it, she'll still KNOW IT -- of course that's a separate issue entirely)
- most of the broken tiles and those "let's follow the footsteps" game will be covered by the panels -- again functionally having black footprints doesn't impact performance (that won't cause leaks) but again it goes with the point above (you know it's there). In fact my wife is pretty upset about the tile cracks that I didn't even want to bring up the footprint or think she'll probably loose it.
I'm actually beginning to think that maybe going with the other installer (PetersenDean) which is ALSO a roofing company might have been a better bet and at least they know how to handle roofs (not cause damage and know how to fix them if they do) - they were only about $.30/watt more. But owell, as they said in "Harold and Kumar" we already gone to far to turn back.
I'm writing to my project manager to see what they'll say. Technically in the contract they just warranty against any functional roof damage for 10 years, nothing about aesthetics (not sure if any of them do have that language in the contract). The language also specifically says "will replace or repair at its sole discretion any item it determines to be faulty as a result of errors and/or omissions on the part of Sullivan Solar Power" -- so technically they are not obligated to replace a broken tile.
So we'll see, supposedly they have some lurkers on this forum so I do imagine they do care about their quality reputation so hoping they will make good.
Right now also have my landscape project going on so between that and the solar hard to babysit both. Since landscaping everyone will see, I've been concentrating on that.
Yeah another one to add to the tips: don't try to have too many house projects going on at once otherwise you won't be able to monitor them at the level you want.
For now subscribing to the philosophy of you "need to crack some eggs to make an omelette". I'm just hoping they don't break any more....<sigh>.
Just some of the pictures of the wonderful glue used to repair my broken tiles:
Legally and contractually don't really see anything they are doing wrong, it's just more about the quality and care of the work. A bit surprising as others on this forum have used this company with great praise.
More tips:
- If you care about how your roof tiles look then make sure you really understand the expectation during your installation and get that in writing
- Know your tiles and how brittle they are, this will give you an idea of the level of "damage" to expect during install
- Procure your extra tiles AND paint ahead of time (you need to supply the materials unless it's specifically written in the contract)
- Again if you care how your roof looks, regularly check the progress and get ON the roof, don't take their word for it (it's not their house, it's yours). If you really care then get up there to inspect (do it before, when they do the brackets and rails, before they install the panels, and after they install the panels).
In my case I'm going with a well known reputable installer in my area (Sullivan, which many here have used and one of the reasons why I decided to go with them). At any rate even in the contract language (I checked), in my case they warranty the roof work for 10 years against leaks. Now having a functional non-leaking roof doesn't necessarily mean a pristine looking roof with no tiles that were repaired by glue.
My entire roof is Spanish concrete tiles, now it's more durable than the flat concrete tiles which are real brittle but none the less I've had my share of headaches with broken tiles, already 10 cracks and I'm considered a small install 4.23KW (only 18 panels).
Worst one of the installers stepped in that black stuff they use to seal the bolts into the roof (under the tiles) and now have a number of "follow the footprints" on my roof -- argh!!!
I even got 21 extra tiles, yet when I went to the roof to check progress they went ahead and decided to just glue (okay if it's a clean single break -- fine, but some of them are multiple lines and the glue just looks real sloppy).
Maybe I'm too small of a job for them to care about so they want to get done as quick as possible (gluing cheaper than replacing) but still.
In reality:
- gluing a clean tile break does work (confirmed with my roofing company that it's a valid repair -- this goes into it works but ain't pretty pile -- if that's the case then duct tape probably work too!)
- talking to my builder the Spanish tiles are more for aesthetics (yes it does repeal rain) but the real protection is the sheeting that's underneath
- I have a tall two story roof and where the cracked tiles are no one will be able to tell unless you're walking on the roof (although this argument doesn't work too well with the wife since just because she can't see it, she'll still KNOW IT -- of course that's a separate issue entirely)
- most of the broken tiles and those "let's follow the footsteps" game will be covered by the panels -- again functionally having black footprints doesn't impact performance (that won't cause leaks) but again it goes with the point above (you know it's there). In fact my wife is pretty upset about the tile cracks that I didn't even want to bring up the footprint or think she'll probably loose it.
I'm actually beginning to think that maybe going with the other installer (PetersenDean) which is ALSO a roofing company might have been a better bet and at least they know how to handle roofs (not cause damage and know how to fix them if they do) - they were only about $.30/watt more. But owell, as they said in "Harold and Kumar" we already gone to far to turn back.
I'm writing to my project manager to see what they'll say. Technically in the contract they just warranty against any functional roof damage for 10 years, nothing about aesthetics (not sure if any of them do have that language in the contract). The language also specifically says "will replace or repair at its sole discretion any item it determines to be faulty as a result of errors and/or omissions on the part of Sullivan Solar Power" -- so technically they are not obligated to replace a broken tile.
So we'll see, supposedly they have some lurkers on this forum so I do imagine they do care about their quality reputation so hoping they will make good.
Right now also have my landscape project going on so between that and the solar hard to babysit both. Since landscaping everyone will see, I've been concentrating on that.
Yeah another one to add to the tips: don't try to have too many house projects going on at once otherwise you won't be able to monitor them at the level you want.
For now subscribing to the philosophy of you "need to crack some eggs to make an omelette". I'm just hoping they don't break any more....<sigh>.
Just some of the pictures of the wonderful glue used to repair my broken tiles:
Legally and contractually don't really see anything they are doing wrong, it's just more about the quality and care of the work. A bit surprising as others on this forum have used this company with great praise.
More tips:
- If you care about how your roof tiles look then make sure you really understand the expectation during your installation and get that in writing
- Know your tiles and how brittle they are, this will give you an idea of the level of "damage" to expect during install
- Procure your extra tiles AND paint ahead of time (you need to supply the materials unless it's specifically written in the contract)
- Again if you care how your roof looks, regularly check the progress and get ON the roof, don't take their word for it (it's not their house, it's yours). If you really care then get up there to inspect (do it before, when they do the brackets and rails, before they install the panels, and after they install the panels).
Comment