X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • room7
    Junior Member
    • Apr 2012
    • 7

    #1

    Costco REC SunRun

    Here is the information I have, let me know if you need more info to provide better response. Im a noob at this so please be kind

    Locatoin: Inland Empire, CA (So. Cal Desert)
    Seller: REC (Through Costco)
    Producer: SunRun
    Upfront payment: $31,734
    Year 1 output: 16,404 kWhs
    Cost per kWh: $0.102
    Terms: 20year (insured/monitoring included); option to purchase at FMV
    Panel: The salesman told me he would install a Australian panel (he said there is also 2 other Chinese panels, if all things are the same I would rather Australian then a Chinese product)
    Inverter: I dont know; is this something I should ask?
    Current SEC Bill: ~$3500/yr for past 5 years

    Is this a good deal? What else should I ask before signing? suggestions?
  • Naptown
    Solar Fanatic
    • Feb 2011
    • 6880

    #2
    The real number to compare is the cost per watt nameplate DC
    You gave output numbers
    NABCEP certified Technical Sales Professional

    [URL="http://www.solarpaneltalk.com/showthread.php?5334-Solar-Off-Grid-Battery-Design"]http://www.solarpaneltalk.com/showth...Battery-Design[/URL]

    [URL]http://www.calculator.net/voltage-drop-calculator.html[/URL] (Voltage drop Calculator among others)

    [URL="http://www.gaisma.com"]www.gaisma.com[/URL]

    Comment

    • room7
      Junior Member
      • Apr 2012
      • 7

      #3
      Originally posted by Naptown
      The real number to compare is the cost per watt nameplate DC
      You gave output numbers
      when I searched the contract for "DC" all I found was the following:

      System Specifications
      Premium 10.00 kW (DC) Yingli Energy
      (China) system
      System is estimated to produce 16,404kWh
      of solar energy in Year 1
      System will offset 99% of your electricity
      usage with solar power

      If this is not it, sorry but I don't understand what you are asking for

      Comment

      • Naptown
        Solar Fanatic
        • Feb 2011
        • 6880

        #4
        That's the number I was looking for.
        You can probably do better with another vendor. The cost before incentives in this case is just over 3.00 a watt. On systems of this size you should probably be looking in the 3.50 a watt range given the same specs.
        Yingli is a Chinese manufacturer but tier ones among quality stuff.
        A cash deal that would be equal to the lease as you would get the 30% federal credit you could add almost 50% to the lease price and the costs would be equal. ( actually multiply lease cost by 1.45 to come up with the same net cost as the lease and add any utility or state rebates to that.
        Since you are in California you might also look at just shaving the top tiers where the larger expenses for electric are and getting a smaller system.
        NABCEP certified Technical Sales Professional

        [URL="http://www.solarpaneltalk.com/showthread.php?5334-Solar-Off-Grid-Battery-Design"]http://www.solarpaneltalk.com/showth...Battery-Design[/URL]

        [URL]http://www.calculator.net/voltage-drop-calculator.html[/URL] (Voltage drop Calculator among others)

        [URL="http://www.gaisma.com"]www.gaisma.com[/URL]

        Comment

        • room7
          Junior Member
          • Apr 2012
          • 7

          #5
          Originally posted by Naptown
          That's the number I was looking for.
          You can probably do better with another vendor. The cost before incentives in this case is just over 3.00 a watt. On systems of this size you should probably be looking in the 3.50 a watt range given the same specs.
          Yingli is a Chinese manufacturer but tier ones among quality stuff.
          A cash deal that would be equal to the lease as you would get the 30% federal credit you could add almost 50% to the lease price and the costs would be equal. ( actually multiply lease cost by 1.45 to come up with the same net cost as the lease and add any utility or state rebates to that.
          Since you are in California you might also look at just shaving the top tiers where the larger expenses for electric are and getting a smaller system.
          Thanks for the info, from what I understand in the contract if i buy outright I wouldnt get the monitoring or warranty and would have to pay at the end for the removal. The salesman told us it would cost around $8k additional if we wanted to buy outright and get theses services.

          What equation did you use to get to the "3.00 a Watt"?

          I dont think a smaller system is a solution for us. We are planning on purchasing electric cars in the future as well so our usage would only increase.

          Comment

          • Naptown
            Solar Fanatic
            • Feb 2011
            • 6880

            #6
            You could still have monitoring but you are correct the 20 year warranty you would not have. Best case 10 from a reputable dealer.
            If you pirchased why would you have it removed? It's yours and will produce long after 20 years is up.
            The equation I used is cost / DC watts
            In your case it came out about $3.17 a watt.
            If you purchase and therefore can claim the 30% credit the purchase cost can be much higher ( about 45% higher ) to land you at the same cost as the lease.
            This deal doesn't seem that great and you should shop and you can so better.
            NABCEP certified Technical Sales Professional

            [URL="http://www.solarpaneltalk.com/showthread.php?5334-Solar-Off-Grid-Battery-Design"]http://www.solarpaneltalk.com/showth...Battery-Design[/URL]

            [URL]http://www.calculator.net/voltage-drop-calculator.html[/URL] (Voltage drop Calculator among others)

            [URL="http://www.gaisma.com"]www.gaisma.com[/URL]

            Comment

            • silversaver
              Solar Fanatic
              • Jul 2013
              • 1390

              #7
              You should be able to find a 10kW DC solar system for $35,000 or less. You can claim your 30% Federal incentive that will put your net cost $24,500. Why would you pay $31k to "lease" than own? Just because lease company give you 20 years warranty? If you think pre-paid lease make sense, do it.

              Comment

              • room7
                Junior Member
                • Apr 2012
                • 7

                #8
                Originally posted by Naptown
                You could still have monitoring but you are correct the 20 year warranty you would not have. Best case 10 from a reputable dealer.
                If you pirchased why would you have it removed? It's yours and will produce long after 20 years is up.
                The equation I used is cost / DC watts
                In your case it came out about $3.17 a watt.
                If you purchase and therefore can claim the 30% credit the purchase cost can be much higher ( about 45% higher ) to land you at the same cost as the lease.
                This deal doesn't seem that great and you should shop and you can so better.
                You said I should be looking for something around $3.5 a watt? wouldnt lower be better? if costs went down to $1...it would be $.00001 a watt, wouldnt that be good?

                Comment

                • silversaver
                  Solar Fanatic
                  • Jul 2013
                  • 1390

                  #9
                  Originally posted by room7
                  You said I should be looking for something around $3.5 a watt? wouldnt lower be better? if costs went down to $1...it would be $.00001 a watt, wouldnt that be good?
                  call ​google says that number is a scam?, they are offering free solar.
                  Last edited by russ; 09-23-2013, 03:25 AM.

                  Comment

                  • Beachnut
                    Member
                    • Aug 2013
                    • 56

                    #10
                    Originally posted by room7
                    Here is the information I have, let me know if you need more info to provide better response. Im a noob at this so please be kind

                    Locatoin: Inland Empire, CA (So. Cal Desert)
                    Seller: REC (Through Costco)
                    Producer: SunRun
                    Upfront payment: $31,734
                    Year 1 output: 16,404 kWhs
                    Cost per kWh: $0.102
                    Terms: 20year (insured/monitoring included); option to purchase at FMV
                    Panel: The salesman told me he would install a Australian panel (he said there is also 2 other Chinese panels, if all things are the same I would rather Australian then a Chinese product)
                    Inverter: I dont know; is this something I should ask?
                    Current SEC Bill: ~$3500/yr for past 5 years

                    Is this a good deal? What else should I ask before signing? suggestions?
                    We just signed with Rec Solar & Sunrun after a month of research and comparing 3 other bids. My biggest reason for going pre-paid Sunrun lease was the warranty for 20 years Vs. the potential of "whichever" panel or inverter manufacturer going out of business in way less time. SO many have gone belly up in the last few years! Don't let it scare you away from solar, but do consider it in evaluating all out purchase and manufacturer warranty Vs. pre-paid Sunrun lease.



                    Yes, Sunrun could go belly up to, but not likely, until the near 20 year mark when these systems they own need to start coming off, or be bought at FMV. (It seems the highest solar system failure is the inverter, costing around $2K, and lasting about 12 years on average before needing replacement). My 2nd highest reason for going Sunrun is my roof will need replacing after 20 years, (its 8 years old now), and either way, the panels would have to come off to replace my roof. This way, THEY get to pay to remove them, not me. 3rd highest reason, locking in a very low power price, Vs. facing inflation. PG&E has near tripled in price over the last 30 years as I have a 1984 PG&E bill, showing the lowest tier was at .05 cents per kwh Vs. today, it is .13 cents for lowest tier.

                    Your system costs seem high though! We do not use that much power, so we are getting just a smaller 3.06 kwh system, or 12 panels. Yet, we will be paying .097 cents per kwh, and our cost / watt is at very good $2.639. You can see the discussion on how to figure cost per watt on my thread here:



                    I am also surprised your Rec solar dealer is not using the Rec panels?? We are getting the REC 250-PE, which I believe were said to be made in Singapore out of "mostly US parts"...



                    I would get more bids, then negotiate with your Rec dealer some more... Try to get the lowest cost per watt out of your installer. Oh, do read the lease agreements as there are some real BAD ones out their. Sunrun is complicated, but seemed the best of the bunch, by far!!

                    Comment

                    • silversaver
                      Solar Fanatic
                      • Jul 2013
                      • 1390

                      #11
                      Originally posted by Beachnut
                      We just signed with Rec Solar & Sunrun after a month of research and comparing 3 other bids. My biggest reason for going pre-paid Sunrun lease was the warranty for 20 years Vs. the potential of "whichever" panel or inverter manufacturer going out of business in way less time. SO many have gone belly up in the last few years! Don't let it scare you away from solar, but do consider it in evaluating all out purchase and manufacturer warranty Vs. pre-paid Sunrun lease.



                      Yes, Sunrun could go belly up to, but not likely, until the near 20 year mark when these systems they own need to start coming off, or be bought at FMV. (It seems the highest solar system failure is the inverter, costing around $2K, and lasting about 12 years on average before needing replacement). My 2nd highest reason for going Sunrun is my roof will need replacing after 20 years, (its 8 years old now), and either way, the panels would have to come off to replace my roof. This way, THEY get to pay to remove them, not me. 3rd highest reason, locking in a very low power price, Vs. facing inflation. PG&E has near tripled in price over the last 30 years as I have a 1984 PG&E bill, showing the lowest tier was at .05 cents per kwh Vs. today, it is .13 cents for lowest tier.

                      Your system costs seem high though! We do not use that much power, so we are getting just a smaller 3.06 kwh system, or 12 panels. Yet, we will be paying .097 cents per kwh, and our cost / watt is at very good $2.639. You can see the discussion on how to figure cost per watt on my thread here:



                      I am also surprised your Rec solar dealer is not using the Rec panels?? We are getting the REC 250-PE, which I believe were said to be made in Singapore out of "mostly US parts"...



                      I would get more bids, then negotiate with your Rec dealer some more... Try to get the lowest cost per watt out of your installer. Oh, do read the lease agreements as there are some real BAD ones out their. Sunrun is complicated, but seemed the best of the bunch, by far!!

                      An Average 3kW system cost around $12,000 and after CSI and Fed incentive net about $8k. If you choose good solar panels will last 25+ years and they aren't easy to break especially in Socal with nice weather here. If you choose SMA inverter, the 20 years premium (cover labor) extended warranty will cost you $625 (For Fronius, $540). If you roll that to the total cost lets say $8,500 after incentive. Most of installers have referral program around $500, but you got $700, After all, you have manage to get the pre-paid worry free lease for $7378. You save about $600 to $700 over all, good job!

                      Comment

                      • room7
                        Junior Member
                        • Apr 2012
                        • 7

                        #12
                        I got them down to 29600 for a 9.95Kwh System with REC 255 panels. Good deal? If not what number should I ask for?

                        Comment

                        • room7
                          Junior Member
                          • Apr 2012
                          • 7

                          #13
                          I got them down to 29600 for a 9.95Kwh System with REC 255 panels. Good deal? If not what number should I ask for?

                          The inverters are Power-one pvi 4.2 outs and Power-one pvi 3.6

                          Comment

                          • Beachnut
                            Member
                            • Aug 2013
                            • 56

                            #14
                            If you are saying your paying $29600.00 for a 9.95kwh system that would be $2.974 per kwh price. Is that $29600.00 before incentives (tax rebates, & referral rebates)? If it is,, your doing better than I did at $3.96 pre tax / pre referral rebate price. (My post tax incentive / referral rebate price is $2.41 per kwh). I wish they would start a topic / category for "What did you pay per kwh for your system" so we all could see what others are paying, in various regions. I am sure it varies state to state, region to region, but it would sure give everyone a target to shoot for. I am sure it would not make contractors too happy though!

                            I did get a lower cost bid, but it was from Solar City, and I did not like there pre-paid lease contract wording, and they were not a "local" contractor. You really have to insure your getting quality, not just a cheap price, as sometimes going "cheap" bite's ya back in problems later on, or in installation. Do look at Yelp, Google, and BBB reviews also.

                            Disclaimer,, I am for sure, no expert in this. I just did my homework, as everyone should do, and these are just the personal opinions I have formed after doing that.

                            Comment

                            • room7
                              Junior Member
                              • Apr 2012
                              • 7

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Beachnut
                              If you are saying your paying $29600.00 for a 9.95kwh system that would be $2.974 per kwh price. Is that $29600.00 before incentives (tax rebates, & referral rebates)? If it is,, your doing better than I did at $3.96 pre tax / pre referral rebate price. (My post tax incentive / referral rebate price is $2.41 per kwh). I wish they would start a topic / category for "What did you pay per kwh for your system" so we all could see what others are paying, in various regions. I am sure it varies state to state, region to region, but it would sure give everyone a target to shoot for. I am sure it would not make contractors too happy though!

                              I did get a lower cost bid, but it was from Solar City, and I did not like there pre-paid lease contract wording, and they were not a "local" contractor. You really have to insure your getting quality, not just a cheap price, as sometimes going "cheap" bite's ya back in problems later on, or in installation. Do look at Yelp, Google, and BBB reviews also.

                              Disclaimer,, I am for sure, no expert in this. I just did my homework, as everyone should do, and these are just the personal opinions I have formed after doing that.
                              no incentives, it is a prepaid lease. What incentives would I qualify for?

                              Comment

                              Working...