22.3KW Self install complete, $1.25/W!

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • JFinch57
    Solar Fanatic
    • Feb 2015
    • 159

    #1

    22.3KW Self install complete, $1.25/W!

    Total cost for ground & roof panels after $1K state grant and 30% federal tax credit ~ $28K/22.3KW= $1.25/W. The price and KW includes 6 additional panels that I will be adding to the ground array. Picture of Phase II roof panels just completed:IMG_5520.jpg

    Phase I ground array completed June 2014. I have trimmed the maple tree on the right since the picture was taken: Soar Panels Done2.jpg
    Jeff, BSEE, 22.3KW, 45-240W w/M190, 46-260W w/M250
  • 8.4
    Junior Member
    • Oct 2015
    • 42

    #2
    Is it safe to assume you'll never have to pay for power?

    Comment

    • JFinch57
      Solar Fanatic
      • Feb 2015
      • 159

      #3
      Originally posted by 8.4
      Is it safe to assume you'll never have to pay for power?
      Getting there, house is 100% electric, has 9 tons of geothermal and is 6,500 sq. ft. Our use averages ~3,500 KWh/month so we're about 2/3. I'm loosing about 50% on the roof in the winter months due to shading. My wife doesn't want to know about topping trees, which we did in our last house and she says it's ugly. Still working on that! A good percentage goes to heating the lower level to keep my mother in law warm.
      Jeff, BSEE, 22.3KW, 45-240W w/M190, 46-260W w/M250

      Comment

      • bcroe
        Solar Fanatic
        • Jan 2012
        • 5209

        #4
        Originally posted by JFinch57
        Total cost for ground & roof panels after $1K state grant and 30% federal tax credit ~ $28K/22.3KW= $1.25/W. The price and KW includes 6 additional panels that I will be adding to the ground array. Picture of Phase II roof panels just completed

        Phase I ground array completed June 2014. I have trimmed the maple tree on the right since the picture was taken
        Very nice, and economical; does that price include inverters? I suppose you couldn't get the
        ground mount any farther from those trees? Mine are in my largest clearing, but the clearing
        has been gradually getting bigger.

        My eyeball says the angle of the ground mount elevation angle is too low for good winter
        production; are you mostly relying on summer KWHs? Its going to be tough to generate
        42,000 KWH a year where there are clouds & snow. Bruce Roe

        Comment

        • JFinch57
          Solar Fanatic
          • Feb 2015
          • 159

          #5
          Bruce, The ground mount is at 30 degrees and didn't do too bad last winter. There are large evergreens not in the picture to the left. My wife is anti tree removal and topping, but I'm slowly working on that. I've trimmed the maple tree back a bit. I'm getting a travel lift to paint the back side of the house in the spring, and that will also work great for pruning! It's the roof mount that won't do well in the winter at 14 degrees and behind the trees and to the right. I'm hoping to put at lease 4 of my extra 6 panels hinged to the bottom of the ground array to adjust for better summer/winter production. Summer production should be great.

          When they installed the geothermal I put the feed pipe in the same trench which made installation much easier. The roof feeds back to the ground array where there's a dedicated 200A outdoor Square D QO panel and the production meter (3/0 copper line side, #4 neutral, will handle 38KW of AC). I have enough wire in the conduit to add another 24 panels on the roof, one pair capped off and 8 available on one of the strings.

          For the ground mount I had one friend help me build the frame and 2 friends help with the concrete work. After that it's just me with a little help from my wife to pull the wire, and same for the roof.

          The Enphase public site is here, did 65KWh today! Two panels are defective and 480Vfred (from "you know where") is getting me new connection blocks for them. https://enlighten.enphaseenergy.com/...48852/overview

          Yes, the price includes everything. I had 10 Enphase M-190s left over from NJ and bought 35 more for around $90 each. Got the 46 M-250s on Ebay for $130 ea plus shipping. The M250 first 36 cable drops were $15 ea and the last 10 $22 ea. Used all Unirac mounting for both.
          Jeff, BSEE, 22.3KW, 45-240W w/M190, 46-260W w/M250

          Comment

          • bcroe
            Solar Fanatic
            • Jan 2012
            • 5209

            #6
            Originally posted by JFinch57
            Bruce, The ground mount is at 30 degrees and didn't do too bad last winter. There are large evergreens not in the picture to the left. My wife is anti tree removal and topping, but I'm slowly working on that. I've trimmed the maple tree back a bit. I'm getting a travel lift to paint the back side of the house in the spring, and that will also work great for pruning! It's the roof mount that won't do well in the winter at 14 degrees and behind the trees and to the right. I'm hoping to put at lease 4 of my extra 6 panels hinged to the bottom of the ground array to adjust for better summer/winter production. Summer production should be great.

            When they installed the geothermal I put the feed pipe in the same trench which made installation much easier. The roof feeds back to the ground array where there's a dedicated 200A outdoor Square D QO panel and the production meter (3/0 copper line side, #4 neutral, will handle 38KW of AC). I have enough wire in the conduit to add another 24 panels on the roof, one pair capped off and 8 available on one of the strings.

            For the ground mount I had one friend help me build the frame and 2 friends help with the concrete work. After that it's just me with a little help from my wife to pull the wire, and same for the roof.

            The Enphase public site is here, did 65KWh today! Two panels are defective and 480Vfred (from "you know where") is getting me new connection blocks for them. https://enlighten.enphaseenergy.com/...48852/overview

            Yes, the price includes everything. I had 10 Enphase M-190s left over from NJ and bought 35 more for around $90 each. Got the 46 M-250s on Ebay for $130 ea plus shipping. The M250 first 36 cable drops were $15 ea and the last 10 $22 ea. Used all Unirac mounting for both.
            My panels are elevated 25 degrees, which seemed OK for summer and was very convenient
            for erection. Today I could see it was just too low for this time of year. Despite being over
            paneled, the string inverters were shy of clipping. Add the low sun angle shooting through
            more dust, marginal panel elevation, and the short day, production was about 57% of a sunny
            summer day.

            Do you push the snow off the ground mount? I was not willing to give up any energy
            at first. But I have started putting big gaps between panels so the snow can drop through.

            I'm the only one who regularly gets back to the array, so operations aren't much inhibited.
            You can trim trees, but its amazing how fast they try to get back to the old elevation. And
            pruning a big tree can be dangerous; in the air you can't just step back when things start
            to fall. The real fix is just remove them.

            Not sure yet if a big geothermal and smaller solar would have saved me much, but what
            I'm doing is working for now. Can't make it through a really cold winter without any
            resistance heating.

            My "turnkey" south facing array was built up from standard extruded aluminum. After
            the first test fitting of components, I ended up drilling nearly a thousand missing or
            misplaced holes in my shop and erecting all of it. The E-W was very little cost from
            treated wood and a minimum of aluminum, erected solely by me in just one month.

            If I had that size wire, power delivered would pick up 2% or more. But I elected to use
            the wire already buried here. I have dozens of panels from 480Vfred, 2 dead and 2
            poor producers. He eventually replaced those 4; prices were good. Some "cosmetic
            defects" had no mounting holes, but I do have a drill. 40 are currently serving well.
            Bruce Roe

            Comment

            • JFinch57
              Solar Fanatic
              • Feb 2015
              • 159

              #7
              Bruce, when I say the ground panels didn't do bad it is probably ~60% of summer, but they did clip with the Enphase M190s. I use a window washing brush/squeegee on a long telescoping pole to take the snow off and had to do it 2-3X last year. Wasn't that bad to do except my hands practically froze even with North commercial "Polar" gloves on (damn polar vortex!). I can only monitor one of the geothermal units for resistance heating and it was minimal. Have a 4 ton Waterfurnace Series 7 and a 5 ton Waterfurnace Envision. The Series 7 is amazing, and purchased it 1 year later. What a difference in technology between the two units. I like 480v fred but the last panels delivered 5 weeks ago have 8/10 DOA. He's working with me to repair/replace, thinks the lead boxes are bad since I have good voltage from the panel but only 1V coming out. Somebody dropped the ball, rounded up a bunch of panels put aside in the corner! I know he'll make it right. Jeff
              Jeff, BSEE, 22.3KW, 45-240W w/M190, 46-260W w/M250

              Comment

              • bcroe
                Solar Fanatic
                • Jan 2012
                • 5209

                #8
                Originally posted by JFinch57
                Bruce, when I say the ground panels didn't do bad it is probably ~60% of summer, but they did clip with the Enphase M190s. I use a window washing brush/squeegee on a long telescoping pole to take the snow off and had to do it 2-3X last year. Wasn't that bad to do except my hands practically froze even with North commercial "Polar" gloves on (damn polar vortex!). I can only monitor one of the geothermal units for resistance heating and it was minimal. Have a 4 ton Waterfurnace Series 7 and a 5 ton Waterfurnace Envision. The Series 7 is amazing, and purchased it 1 year later. What a difference in technology between the two units. I like 480v fred but the last panels delivered 5 weeks ago have 8/10 DOA. He's working with me to repair/replace, thinks the lead boxes are bad since I have good voltage from the panel but only 1V coming out. Somebody dropped the ball, rounded up a bunch of panels put aside in the corner! I know he'll make it right. Jeff
                Last winter wasn't too bad here; the winter before I was out clearing snow a dozen and a half times, over
                the walkways and drives on these 5 acres, and the PV panels. I use a pair of hand warmers (HotHands)
                to keep my hands comfortable for a couple hours. These are claimed to work for 12 hours, seemed like
                a waste. So after use I put them in a very small, air tight container to stop the reaction, and I am able
                to use them a couple more times.

                The technology of variable speed AC motors is changing a lot of processes, but it always involves making
                DC to supply the variable frequency inverter. On my future project list is to get a mini split heat pump,
                and see if I can use some panels to supply much of that DC. No PoCo permit required, but they will be
                making up any shortfall. The car shop has room for a lot of panels on the metal walls, and I would have
                the mini split run anytime appreciable sun is available, trying to always keep the interior above freezing.
                I blast it up to 60F with propane for serious work.

                Fred has some kind of EE credentials, but I'm not convinced he understands PV panels on the level we
                do here. Certainly no test facilities, last time I visited. But we have done good business. Bruce Roe

                Comment

                • foo1bar
                  Solar Fanatic
                  • Aug 2014
                  • 1833

                  #9
                  Originally posted by JFinch57
                  Total cost for ground & roof panels after $1K state grant and 30% federal tax credit ~ $28K/22.3KW= $1.25/W.
                  So before rebates and credits, $41k for 22.3kw or $1.85/W
                  Congratulations.
                  That's better than I did on a pre-tax/pre-rebate basis.

                  Are you willing to share what you spent on materials, labor, services, etc?
                  It probably would be educational to other people contemplating a DIY.

                  Comment

                  • JFinch57
                    Solar Fanatic
                    • Feb 2015
                    • 159

                    #10
                    Ground mount 10.8KW, 45 panels:

                    Solar Panels $8,474.80
                    Electrical Panel/Wire $2,521.68
                    Ground Mounts $7,553.52
                    MicroInverters $3,179.90
                    Permits $120.00

                    Total before tax credit $21,849.90
                    Tax Credit (30%) -$6,554.97
                    State Grant -$1,000.00
                    Total Cost $14,294.93

                    Breakdown Ground Mounts:
                    $1,501.49 Fazzio (pipe/misc)
                    $4,413.38 Allied (Unirac)
                    $115.80 WEEBs
                    $673.50 Cement
                    $400.00 Drill holes (subcontracted)
                    $40.00 N-S Alignment (bought a compass!)
                    $210.55 Home Depot
                    $91.80 Cement Buggy Rental
                    $107.00 Bandsaw Blades

                    Breakdown on Elec Panel/Wiring:
                    $91.00 Meter/Main
                    $70.10 Enphase Harnesses
                    $400.00 Conduit/Misc
                    $186.00 Outdoor Load Center
                    $52.35 Main Breaker
                    $98.84 Main Breaker Panel
                    $1,183.40 United Electric
                    $390.00 Envoy
                    $49.99 Terminal Lug Kit

                    Most items bought on Ebay!

                    I have to figure out the roof system, might take a few days.
                    Jeff, BSEE, 22.3KW, 45-240W w/M190, 46-260W w/M250

                    Comment

                    • solarz
                      Member
                      • Nov 2015
                      • 35

                      #11
                      You buy panel and inverter on Ebay also?
                      5KW Enphase system.

                      Comment

                      • JFinch57
                        Solar Fanatic
                        • Feb 2015
                        • 159

                        #12
                        Originally posted by solarz
                        You buy panel and inverter on Ebay also?
                        Yes, I bought the inverters, panels, Enphase cables, Enphase Envoy, 200A outdoor load center, outdoor meter pan/200A breaker, indoor 200A main breaker, WEEBS, and even some of the #10 TWNW on Ebay. Got open spools of THWN with ~400' left for about $35 delivered.
                        Jeff, BSEE, 22.3KW, 45-240W w/M190, 46-260W w/M250

                        Comment

                        • JFinch57
                          Solar Fanatic
                          • Feb 2015
                          • 159

                          #13
                          Originally posted by foo1bar
                          So before rebates and credits, $41k for 22.3kw or $1.85/W
                          Congratulations.
                          That's better than I did on a pre-tax/pre-rebate basis.

                          Are you willing to share what you spent on materials, labor, services, etc?
                          It probably would be educational to other people contemplating a DIY.
                          Ground mount system on first page, Phase II roof system 36 X 260W + 10 X 255W (all mono panels) = 11.91KW:

                          Solar Panels $9,563.50
                          Electrical Panel/Wire $1,298.22
                          Roof Mounts $2,695.96
                          MicroInverters $6,140.00 (Enphase M-250)
                          Permits ~$120.00

                          Total before tax credit $19,817.68
                          Tax Credit (30%) -$5,945.30
                          Total Cost $13,872.38

                          Breakown:

                          Electrical Panel/Wire/Misc
                          $36.43 Wire-Ebay
                          $40.99 Wire-Ebay
                          $150.00 Wire/Boxes-Home Depot
                          $100.00 Conduit/Misc
                          $37.91 Enphase Brackets
                          $720.00 Enphase Cables-36
                          $212.89 Enphase Cables-10

                          Roof Mounting/Trench
                          $75.00 Fazzio/Stainless Hdw.
                          $1,693.22 Allied-Unirac
                          55.65 Allied-Inverter T bolt
                          68.09 Allied-Add clamps
                          $600.00 Trench Excavation (includes driveway lights)
                          $160.00 Ditch Witch Rental
                          $44.00 Enphase Cable Clips

                          The price also included adding a 200A dedicated solar "pre-main" tap to my 400A service, included with the ground mount system. Total roof & ground ~$41,700 pre-tax for 22.7KW = $1.84/W.
                          Jeff, BSEE, 22.3KW, 45-240W w/M190, 46-260W w/M250

                          Comment

                          • solarz
                            Member
                            • Nov 2015
                            • 35

                            #14
                            Thank you for the info. I just thought Ebay is not the place to buy Solar equipment. It seems I am wrong.
                            5KW Enphase system.

                            Comment

                            • foo1bar
                              Solar Fanatic
                              • Aug 2014
                              • 1833

                              #15
                              Originally posted by solarz
                              Thank you for the info. I just thought Ebay is not the place to buy Solar equipment. It seems I am wrong.
                              I wouldn't (and didn't)

                              If everything works - great.
                              If there's a problem - how do you deal with warranty issues?
                              Why is it being sold on e-bay? Is it refurbished? Other issues?

                              For me the risk wasn't worth the reward.

                              Comment

                              Working...